A- A A+

The less well off left behind

Staff reporter |  10 November 2013  |  Super

 BehindThe Abbott government's attitude towards superannuation is relatively clear in the decision to remove the tax on incomes above $100,000 and the removal of advantages for lower income workers. There is no interest here in social equity, as the AFR makes clear. It describes the decision to dump the rebate for low-income earners as "inexcusable":

"Sure, the low-income rebate was tied to the mining tax, which is also on the government’s chopping board. But the Coalition conveniently unbundled the super guarantee from the very same mining tax, presumably because there were votes on doing so."

The AFR points out that Tony Abbott has promised to retain the rise in the super guarantee to 12 per cent from 9 per cent. He is "insisting that his promise is still good", even though the rise will be delayed by two years.

"Scrapping the low-income rebate, which is worth up to $500 a year, will mean that the lowest paid 3.6 million (mostly female) workers will not receive the full benefit of the 15 per cent concessional tax rate on super contributions. At the other end of the scale, individuals earning more than $180,000 receive a huge benefit.


"Their super contributions, which would otherwise be taxed at 45 per cent, are levied at 15 per cent. Finding a way of reinstating the rebate, known in the industry as low- income super contribution (LISC), is imperative. Last week industry super funds suggested areas where money could be found to pay for the rebate, such as watering down the proposed paid parental leave scheme or axing the co-contribution super scheme.

"Arguably, doing either of these would also hit women adversely. The government could and should look much further than these measures.

"Generous schemes such as transition to retirement pensions could be revisited, as could the age at which individuals can start drawing down super, or the amount of pension assets that are tax-free. Unfortunately the wealth industry probably shouldn’t hold its collective breath for a U-turn any time soon. Even if Assistant Treasurer Arthur Sinodinos understands the argument (and by all accounts he does), the government is hamstrung by its promise not to make any adverse changes to super in its first term."

What is clear is that the Aboott government is going to leave super as intact as it can. It is unlikely there will be any attempts to tap into the pot of money, at least for the next three years. The political cost would be too great, although for lower income workers the risk is apparently worth taking.





Similar articles from Super

What you should know about financial advisers

 | 11/27/2013

“Adviser”There is a debate about how much disclosure financial advisers. The Institute of Chartered Accountants has weighed into the debate saying some suggestions do not address the serious systemic issues.

Farmers get benefits from SMSFs

PSI | 11/26/2013

Andrew LairdFarmers can get great advantages from SMSFs if they go about it the right way. But there are traps and pitfalls says one financial adviser.

The 'sophisticated investor' trap

Staff reporter | 11/25/2013

“sophisticated”If you have $5 million in your DIY super fund you are a retail investor, but if you have $5 million as an individual you are a wholesale investor and considered "sophisticated". Go figure. It is one of the contradictions of the new financial advice laws.

The dangers of financial advisers

PSI | 11/19/2013

Adviser New rules on financial advice will change the industry but clients are advised to be extremely cautious. There are gaps in the rules and the risks still remain.

Well off pensioners duck a bullet

Staff reporter | 10/28/2013

BulletProposals by the previous government appeared to only target the very rich super fund members, but there were a number of hidden dangers. And SMSF investors are potentially the most vulnerable, especially those using debt and looking to get large, one off capital gains.



Subscribe to the Personal Super Investor weekly email to keep abreast of developments in SMSF law and investment markets. SMSF investors looking to improve investment returns from shares, property, cash or other specialised investments, will find the PSI weekly newsletter an invaluable resource.

Subscribe now »